Is there any relationship between bullies or their victims and Emotional Intelligence? If so, what would the relationship look like? This was the subject of Stacy Vogel’s doctoral dissertation at Northcentral University in Arizona. Surveys have found that as many as 23% of school children report being bullied over a three-month period.
Stacy’s study included 235 fourth and fifth grade students who were tested with several bully/victim questionnaires and the Emotional Quotient Inventory: Youth Version (EQ-i:YV™). Peer nominations were used to identify both bullies and victims. Bullying/victimization questionnaire scores were highly related to the peer nominations. The study supported a relationship between EI and bullying (but not as complete as expected), but failed to support a prediction that gender would moderate the EI-bullying relationships.
The Intrapersonal scale, for example, did not relate significantly to bullying or victimization. One explanation was that bullies may not see their behavior as being aware of or expressing their feelings to others. Instead, they may view their behavior as simply picking on another classmate.
The Interpersonal scale was significantly related to the bullys’ scores, but not the victims’ scores. As previous studies have found, bullies lack empathy and compassion, have low social competence, and poor interpersonal relationships. Victims, on the other hand, may have fewer friends, but seem to find the quality of their relationships satisfying.
The Stress Management scale was negatively correlated with all the bully/victimization measures except peer-nominated victim. Thus, both bullies and victims seemed to have difficulty performing well under pressure and controlling impulses.
Adaptability did not correlate with being a victim or a bully. It was suggested that some of the questions on this scale may have been interpreted to be more related to academic rather than social situations.
The General Mood scale was negatively correlated with the bullying/victimization scales. Students who scored high as either bullies or victims came out as more unhappy and pessimistic.
Finally, the Total EQ scales came out as significantly negative in relation to both bullies and victims, which can be best explained through the subscales described above.
As seen in other studies, bullying was found to occur more frequently between boys than girls. The study made some suggestions related to EI programs in schools and perhaps how they might be streamlined to focus on those areas that were found most relevant to bullying and victimization. The study also suggested using additional measures, like the soon-to-be-released MSCEIT Youth Version (MSCEIT:YV), to see how EI abilities contribute to bullying/victimization.
Reference:
Vogel, Stacey W. (January, 2006). The Relationship Between Bullying and Emotional Intelligence. A doctoral dissertation submitted to the Graduate Faculty of the Department of Psychology at Northcentral University, Prescott, Arizona.